In a new proposal, New York Governor Kathy Hochul is looking to give law enforcement the authority to use the smell of cannabis as a factor in determining reasonable cause during traffic stops. If passed, this measure would partially reverse a rule set in 2021 that prohibited police from using marijuana odor as grounds for a vehicle search.
What the New Proposal Means
Since the legalization of recreational cannabis in New York, police officers have been restricted from using its smell as a reason to conduct searches. However, under Governor Hochul’s new plan, the scent of marijuana could be used to justify further investigation—particularly in cases where a crash or personal injury is involved.
The proposal does not completely reinstate the pre-legalization policies, but it does grant law enforcement a way to use cannabis odor as supporting evidence in certain situations. One significant change includes allowing the smell of marijuana to justify a court-ordered blood test to determine if a driver was under the influence.
Concerns from Advocates
While supporters of the proposal believe it could help keep roads safer, some civil rights advocates and cannabis legalization supporters worry about the potential for overuse or misuse by police officers.
They argue that this change might lead to unnecessary or biased searches, especially in cases where officers make subjective judgments based on smell alone. The fear is that such a law could disproportionately affect specific communities, as seen in past incidents where traffic stops were frequently linked to racial profiling.
Why Law Enforcement Supports the Change
From a law enforcement perspective, this measure is seen as a necessary step in addressing drug-impaired driving. Officers have reported challenges in enforcing DUI (Driving Under the Influence) laws related to cannabis since they currently have fewer tools to determine whether a driver is impaired.
Unlike alcohol, which can be measured with a breathalyzer, marijuana intoxication is harder to detect on the spot. By allowing officers to use odor as supporting evidence, law enforcement groups believe it will be easier to identify potential impaired drivers and make roads safer.
How This Could Affect New York Drivers
If the proposal is approved, drivers should be aware of the following key points:
- Cannabis odor alone may not be enough for an immediate arrest, but it could be used to justify further investigation if combined with other factors, such as reckless driving or visible impairment.
- Blood tests could be ordered if a driver is involved in an accident that results in injuries, and the smell of cannabis is present.
- Legal challenges may arise, as defense attorneys could argue that smell is not an accurate indicator of impairment, considering cannabis odor can linger on clothes and vehicles even if a person is not currently under the influence.
What Happens Next?
Governor Hochul’s proposal is still under discussion and would need legislative approval before becoming law. If passed, it could mark a shift in how cannabis-related traffic stops are handled in New York.
For now, drivers should stay informed and understand that even though recreational cannabis is legal, driving under its influence remains a punishable offense. The debate continues over whether the smell of marijuana should be considered enough evidence to warrant further police action.
Disclaimer – Our team has carefully fact-checked this article to make sure it’s accurate and free from any misinformation. We’re dedicated to keeping our content honest and reliable for our readers.
